What is W2 vs 1099?
Definition: W2 and 1099 are IRS tax forms that distinguish between employees (W2) who have taxes withheld by employers, and independent contractors (1099) who are responsible for paying their own taxes on income received.
Also known as: Employee vs Contractor, W-2 vs 1099, 1099 vs W2
Quick Summary
TL;DRW2 and 1099 refer to IRS tax forms that distinguish employees from independent contractors. W2 workers have taxes withheld and receive benefits; 1099 workers handle their own taxes and work independently. The classification affects tax obligations, benefits, worker protections, and legal compliance for both workers and employers.
Key Facts
W2 Workers
Traditional employees
Employment law
1099 Workers
Independent contractors
IRS classification
Tax Handling
Withheld vs self-paid
Tax requirements
Misclassification Risk
Significant penalties
DOL enforcement
Why W2 vs 1099 Classification Matters
Misclassifying workers is one of the most common and costly compliance mistakes. The IRS, DOL, and state agencies actively audit staffing firms for misclassification. Penalties include back taxes, benefits, overtime pay, and fines up to $50 per misclassified worker. Beyond compliance, the classification affects recruiting conversations—candidates need to understand the real difference in take-home pay and benefits.
Common Pain Points
- 1IRS audits for worker misclassification
- 2Back tax liability for misclassified workers
- 3Candidates confused about actual take-home pay
- 4State-by-state classification rules adding complexity
Understanding W2 vs 1099 Classification
Use the IRS factors to determine correct classification.
- 1
Behavioral Control Test
Does the company control how work is done? Controlling methods = W2. Controlling only results = 1099.
- 2
Financial Control Test
Who controls business aspects? Company provides tools/training = W2. Worker has business expenses = 1099.
- 3
Relationship Type Test
Is this ongoing employment? Written contracts, benefits, permanence suggest W2. Project-based suggests 1099.
- 4
Document Everything
Maintain clear documentation of the working relationship, contracts, and classification rationale for audit protection.
Result
When in doubt, consult employment counsel—the cost of advice is far less than misclassification penalties.
W2 vs 1099 Deep Dive for Staffing
Tax and Pay Implications
W2 employees have 7.65% FICA taxes withheld, with the employer paying another 7.65%. 1099 contractors pay the full 15.3% self-employment tax themselves. A $60/hour W2 role might need to be $70-75/hour as 1099 for equivalent take-home pay. Always help candidates understand the true comparison.
Common Misclassification Scenarios
Red flags for misclassification: long-term 'contractors' with single clients, workers using company equipment exclusively, set schedules with required hours, company-controlled work methods, and workers integrated into company teams. These factors often indicate the worker should be W2.
State Variations
California's AB5 and similar state laws use stricter tests like the ABC test. Under ABC, workers are presumed employees unless the company proves: (A) worker is free from control, (B) work is outside usual business, (C) worker has independent business. Staffing agencies must know each state's rules.
Common Misconceptions
- Workers can choose their classification
- 1099 always means more money
- Small companies don't get audited for misclassification
- Using contracts makes someone a 1099
W2 vs 1099 Comparison
| Factor | W2 Employee | 1099 Contractor |
|---|---|---|
| Tax Withholding | Employer withholds | Self-paid quarterly |
| FICA/Medicare | Split 50/50 with employer | Pay full 15.3% |
| Benefits | Typically provided | None from client |
| Work Control | Employer directs | Worker controls |
| Equipment | Usually provided | Usually own |
| Schedule | Set by employer | Flexible |
Key differences between employment types
Related Terms
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Resources
Streamline Your Staffing Operations
Professional resume formatting for any employment type